diff --git a/playwright-tests/pages/SchedulePage.ts b/playwright-tests/pages/SchedulePage.ts
index 8c8f3f8c..ede5668b 100644
--- a/playwright-tests/pages/SchedulePage.ts
+++ b/playwright-tests/pages/SchedulePage.ts
@@ -31,8 +31,8 @@ export class SchedulePage extends BasePage {
         super(page);
         this.page = page;
 
-        this.inShopButton = this.page.locator('[buttonlabel="At a Safelite shop"]');
-        this.mobileButton = this.page.locator('[buttonlabel="Have Safelite come to me"]');
+        this.inShopButton = this.page.getByText('At a Safelite shop');
+        this.mobileButton = this.page.getByText('Have Safelite come to me');
         // For in shop
         this.moreLocationsButton = this.page.getByRole('button', { name: 'More Locations' });
         // For mobile
@@ -77,6 +77,7 @@ export class SchedulePage extends BasePage {
                 await (await this.getFirstNonDropOffTimeSlot()).click();
             }
             } else {
+                await this.inShopButton.click();
                 await (await this.getFirstNonDropOffTimeSlot()).click();
             }
         } else {